KAR Global CFO Eric Loughmiller will retire at the end of 2022, the company announced.
The wholesale auctions provider is conducting a national search for Loughmiller’s replacement and aims to fill the role before he retires, KAR CEO Peter Kelly told investors and analysts Wednesday on the company’s third-quarter earnings call.
KAR reported higher year-over-year revenue, more profits per each vehicle sold and a net profit from its continuing operations in the quarter that ended Sept. 30, though Kelly noted continued wariness about reduced conversion rates at auctions.
KAR reported a $500,000 net profit from continuing operations, which include its digital and hybrid wholesaling units such as BacklotCars, Openlane, Carwave and TradeRev. That’s compared with a $26.9 million net loss one year ago.
However, KAR recorded a net loss of $5.8 million in the quarter that ended Sept. 30. That figure factors in a loss of $6.3 million from the company’s discontinued operations, which pertains to ADESA U.S., the large auction unit it sold to Carvana Co. on May 9. KAR now lists ADESA U.S. as discontinued operations on its financial statement.
KAR’s total revenue in the quarter, not including ADESA U.S. operations, was $393 million, up 13 percent from the same period a year ago.
The company’s marketplace segment sold 314,000 total vehicles in the quarter, leaner than the 357,000 sold in the same period a year ago. Gross profit per vehicle sold rose to $320 in the third quarter, up 14 percent. Auction fees per vehicle sold also grew to $283, up 12 percent.
Conversion rates were lower in the third quarter than they were a year ago because used-vehicle values are in decline and buyers are less willing to pay the higher prices sought by many sellers, Kelly said.
The company saw a small bump in conversion rates in August, but for the most part, they’ve remained below 2021 rates, Kelly said.
Conversion rates vary by channel, he added. If a channel had a 60 percent conversion rate in 2021, it’s down to roughly 50 percent this year, he estimated.
Kelly said he expects used-vehicle values to continue declining through at least the fourth quarter. A softening in used-vehicle pricing could be a long-term positive for the business because it will allow more vehicles to flow back into the wholesale channel, he said.
“In the near term, however, a declining market is often characterized by lower conversion rates, and this can be a near-term headwind to the business,” Kelly added.
He told investors and analysts that an industrywide lack of wholesale used-vehicle supply remained evident in the third quarter.
“For example, physical auction volumes, which remain a good proxy for industry volumes, were down 8 percent below the third quarter of last year and were 37 percent below the pre-COVID levels of Q3 2019,” Kelly said.
The latest quarter was the second-lowest quarter for physical auction volumes since the pandemic began, he said.
Finance segment
KAR’s finance segment, AFC, generated $99 million in revenue in the third quarter, up 31 percent from third-quarter 2021. Revenue per loan transaction rose to $250, up 16 percent, and loan transactions grew to 397,000, up 13 percent.
As used-vehicle prices continue to decline and interest rates increase, that tends to increase risks in the finance business, Kelly said.
“While we do anticipate some level of increased risk as we enter 2023, we do not expect it to return to pre-COVID levels,” he said.
KAR Global shares slipped 10.3 percent to $13.31 in Wednesday morning trading.
Q3 revenue from continuing operations: $393 million, up 13 percent from the year-earlier period.
Q3 net income: Net loss of $5.8 million, compared with net loss of $1 million in the year-earlier period.
Q3 net income from continuing operations: Net profit of $500,000, compared with net loss of $26.9 million in the year-earlier period.
Q3 vehicle sales: 314,000 total vehicles, down 12 percent.